2010, the International Year of Biodiversity - Clownfishes.
The United Nations has declared 2010 to be the International Year of Biodiversity. It is a celebration of life on earth and of the value of biodiversity to our lives. The world is invited to take action in 2010 to safeguard the variety of life on earth: biodiversity
As part of the International Year of Biodiversity (IYOB) the IUCN has published a report presenting 10 new climate change flagship species to demonstrate that it’s not just the Polar Bear that’s in trouble.
These 10 species are as follows:
Staghorn corals
Ringed Seal
Leatherback Turtle
Emperor Penguins
Quiver Trees
Clownfish
Arctic Foxes
Salmon
Koalas
Beluga Whales
One thing that is immediately obvious from the list is that 7 of the species are marine animals. The second thing to strike me about this list is that 2 common aquarium animals are included, most worrying of all is the inclusion of the poster animal of the marine aquarium hobby, the clownfish
In this first of two articles I’m going to look at clownfish, the second article will be concerned with Staghorn corals.
Clownfish and Climate Change
Clownfish, or Anemonefish, belong to the Family Pomacentridae, with their vivid orange and white colouration are one of the most familiar species of tropical marine fishes. This familiarity was boosted by the film ‘Finding Nemo’, which featured the Common Clownfish, Amphiprion ocellaris, a mainstay of the marine aquarium hobby.
Clownfish are found in tropical and subtropical areas of the Pacific and Indian Oceans where they are restricted to shallow waters owing to their mutualistic relationship with a small number of specific anemone species. A host anemone can support a colony of several clownfish consisting of one female, one functional male, and a number of subordinate fishes, all non-functional males.
When the female dies the male turns into a female whilst the largest subordinate fish becomes male. Clownfish lay their eggs close by their host anemone, guarding them until they hatch. On hatching the larvae disperse into the water column where they remain for around 8 to 12 days before settling out as juveniles and seeking a host anemone of their own. As larvae develop, chemical signals allow them to detect suitable host anemone.
Research has shown that the larvae that survive to settle out as juveniles tend to return to the reef where they originated so the majority of the survivors do not disperse very far from their parents’ anemone.
There are 28 species of clownfish described to science; all behave in a similar manner, exhibiting reliance on their obligate association with host anemones for survival.
Captive breeding.
Clownfish have been bred in captivity since the early eighties so we have a lot of information about how different environmental conditions such as temperature and pH affect this species. Although it’s interesting to note that the recent studies from the reef, revealing that reduction in ocean pH levels have an affect on clownfish’s ability to detect the chemical signals necessary for locating an anemone host, answer the question of why captive bred clowns are often slow to adopt an anemone in a reef aquarium.
Why are Clownfish vulnerable to the effects of climate change?
Habitat loss: Coral reefs are in decline owing to increased levels of CO2 in the atmosphere. The current level stands at 387 ppm CO2, higher than 350 ppm that many leading scientists say is the safe upper limit for carbon dioxide in our atmosphere, and the level we need to get back to as early as possible to avoid runaway climate change. If CO2 levels reach 450 ppm, predicted to occur by 2030-2040 at the current rates of increase, reefs will be in terminal decline worldwide from mass bleaching, ocean acidification, and other environmental impacts. Clownfish are dependent on anemones for their survival, which most frequently occur on coral reefs.
A couple of examples: the global coral bleaching event of 1998, led to the complete disappearance of several sea-anemone species used by clownfish in the corals reefs around Sesoko Island, Japan, causing local population declines; and take a look at: Reef Ramblings June/July 2008 to see an earlier article about reduction in clownfish numbers on the Great Barrier Reef.
Disruption of navigation: Decrease in ocean pH levels have been shown to affect a clownfish’s ability to detect the chemical signals that allow them to locate a host anemone. This is known to be a particular problem for juveniles as, if they’re unable to locate a host, they’re at greater risk of predation. Juveniles unable to locate a new anemone face the chance of returning to their parental anemone, increasing the likelihood of inbreeding.
Larval development: As ocean temperatures increase we’d expect to see faster development of larval and juvenile clownfishes. This may bring a reduction in dispersal distance with the result of settlement closer to the parental anemone increasing local competition for recruitment to neighboring host anemones. Again increasing the possibility of inbreeding.
Reproductive behavior: Clownfish, along with many other fish species, only reproduce within a narrow temperature range. This presents the possibility that as temperatures increase that there may be a reduction in breeding activity. A secondary problem that we’re familiar with from captive breeding is that high temperatures can have a deleterious affect on egg development.
It’s also worth noting that in the IUCN report, under the heading of “Other threats”, that the marine aquarium industry is singled out for mention, although it does go on to add that the greatest threat is down to human activities, presumably the usual
Can clownfish adapt to climate change?
Currently this is unknown, most species can usually adapt to changes in environmental conditions as long as these change occur slowly over time. As ocean temperatures continue to increase, clownfish and their associated host anemones may be able to shift their ranges southwards to cooler water. However, neither clownfishes, nor their anemones, are particularly mobile so it’s likely that successful relocation to new, more suitable habitats will be limited.
The concern about more rapid larval development, with its resultant limitation on dispersal, raises the question of inbreeding, the consequences of which are unknown.
A further possibility, but one that seems to me unlikely, is whether clownfishes could adapt to seasonal breeding pattern taking advantage of the cooler seasons.
Interestingly, the IUCN report states the one species of clownfish has recently been shown to use soft corals as an alternative habitat, something previously only seen in captivity. This is referenced to Arvedlund, M., and Takemura, A. (2005) Long-term observation in situ of the anemonefish Amphiprion clarkii (Bennett) in association
with a soft coral. Coral Reefs 24, 698-698.
It’s not known if other species of clownfish could adopt other host species, nor whether such associations would have the same value as the present association with anemones.
What can we do?
Whilst climate change does not mean extinction, some species will be able to adapt whilst others will perish. The question is which species will survive and which will perish? Worsening climate change effects are inevitable, even if all CO2 emissions ceased today, because of the lag-effects of the greenhouse gasses already emitted.
It’s up to all of us, along with our governments, to commit to targets to reduce emissions at the earliest opportunity if, we want to slow the pace of climate change and give clownfishes and other species a chance to survive.
If you are a reefkeeper, try to raise awareness of the destructive affects of climate change to the marine environment by using the familiar clownfish as an example of what may be lost.
You can download the IUCN report here: Species and Climate Change
Tim Hayes
Midland Reefs
©2010
| Coral Magazine Volume 3: No.5 £5.25 | SICCE Shark ADV. 400 - 400 L/H £24.97 | Coral Magazine Volume 3: No.5 £5.25 |
Tags: biodiversity, Bleaching, climate change, clown fish, clownfish, Coral, fish, Reef